I voted #1. I do not believe in any type of evolutionary timeline: He created Adam from the dust as a man: He created Eve from Adams rib, fully able to conceive children from the start. He trotted the critters by Adam so he could name them: and they were adult animals, otherwise Adam would not have noticed he was "alone".
No evolution, no multiple gods, no aliens: just God creating everything. All of His creation cries out His name. To myself, it is very simple.